SEASON 4: EPISODE V

Coffee, Chaos, and Clues

Four episodes in, the mystery surrounding Shane Barton grows deeper. In this special recap, James and the team revisit the labyrinth of clues that have emerged: the coffee Shane brewed before his sudden disappearance, the haunting cries of Charlie the bull that morning, and the final moments his family claims to have seen him. Rachael’s testimony-layered with emotion and contradiction-takes center stage, as does the chilling layout of the property where everything began. Join us as we untangle threads, unpack revelations, and question everything we thought we knew.